I also don't believe that the alternative to home-schooling--that is education in a school--is a worse choice. It's just a different choice. I certainly don't believe as the author, Mr. O'Hehir, writes regarding full-day kindergarten that "The real purpose of all this formal schooling is to get the kids out of the house and train them to stand in line and follow instructions while mommy and daddy get back to their ultra-important lives as economic production units." Certainly there are good schools and there are bad schools, but there are a great many terrific schools doing so much more than training kids to stand in line. I suspect that there are good home-schoolers and bad home-schoolers as well.
Mr. O'Hehir seems to understand that, by and large, how we educate our children is a choice. He's saying homeschooling works for him, and I'm glad. I only wish, that by trying to dispel some of the generalizations and myths about home-schooling, he wouldn't have drawn some of his own stereotypes. For the record, Mr. O'Hehir is not a bible-thumping Christian. Does that mean he's not a Christian at all, or that he just doesn't thump his bible? I'm not sure, though I'm pretty sure the distinction shouldn't matter.